Golden Diner's Famous Pancakes

Honey Butter Pancakes

PREP: 1 HR 15 MIN / READY: 1 HR 45 MIN

4-6

Breakfast

Fluffy yeasted pancakes served with honey maple butter, finished with lemon zest.

Ingredients

Yeast Mixture (Poolish)

Dry Mix

Wet Mix

Maple Honey Syrup

Whipped Honey Maple Butter

Berry Compote

Garnish

Instructions

  1. Make Poolish (1 hour):
    • Combine warm water (not too hot), buttermilk, and yeast
    • Mix in first cup of flour until just combined
    • Texture should look like cottage cheese - lumps are good
    • Don't overmix or it will be gummy
    • Cover to prevent skin forming
    • Place in warm (not hot) spot for 1 hour
    • When ready, mixture should feel warm to touch and show active bubbles, with slight sour bread aroma
  2. Mix Dry Ingredients:
    • Important: Salt goes in dry mix to avoid killing yeast
    • Combine remaining flour, sugar, salt, precisely measured baking soda and powder
    • Mix until homogeneous
  3. Make Maple Honey Syrup:
    • Gently melt butter (no browning) - microwave okay
    • In separate bowl, combine honey, soy sauce, maple syrup, and salt
    • Mix until completely homogeneous - one solid color
    • Add to melted butter
    • Add touch of water
    • If using xanthan gum, whisk constantly while adding
  4. Make Berry Compote:
    • Cut strawberries precisely to match blueberry size
    • Mix with sugar and cornstarch
    • Let macerate until white/powdery becomes wet/glazey
    • Cook quickly (1-2 minutes) - mixture will be violent and explosive initially
    • Done when berries become limp but maintain shape
    • Immediately shock in ice bath
  5. Make Final Batter:
    • Mix wet ingredients until no yellow streaks
    • Combine with poolish
    • Gently fold in dry ingredients
    • Batter should look "alive" with bubbles forming and popping
    • Should have distinctive sourdough-like aroma
  6. Cook Pancakes:
    • Position rack 6 inches from broiler, preheat broiler
    • Place pan on medium heat for full 5 minutes
    • Test drop should make gentle sizzle, not angry spitting
    • Pour ½ cup batter
    • Cook until bottom is golden brown
    • Move to cooler part for 30 seconds
    • Finish under broiler until top is set and lightly golden
  7. Plate for Visual Impact:
    • Stack two golden-brown pancakes
    • Add vibrant berry compote
    • Add shaped quenelle of honey maple butter
    • Pour syrup generously - pancakes should be "drenched"
    • Finish with fresh lemon zest

Pro Tips: Trust your senses when cooking - sound and smell are as important as sight. The dark golden bottom won't taste burnt. Cut berries exactly blueberry-sized. Add more syrup than seems reasonable. The finished pancake should be a feast for all senses - visual contrasts, varied textures, balanced flavors. Makes 8-10 pancakes (4-5 servings of 2 pancakes each).